The website's experiencing some inconsistencies, and this is one of them. Make sure the selected thumbnail appears depressed after clicking it. I had your same problem a moment ago (solved by saving the profile), but it appears to be fixed now.
oh boy another one thread. well i want to know what up? i hear lots of people saying, My painting can't save, i can't save my savii. if there a problem, try asking HullBreach about this or just ask in the Help Desk.